I used some reclaimed magnet sheets*, some fun foam and cardstock, paint and paint markers.
Check here to see how much I love them!
I got the big pot of paint on sale at Michaels for about a dollar and the markers (terra cotta) came from a Michaels grabbag.
We gave the top and bottom of the tin a coat of white paint. When it was thoroughly dry, I decorated it.
The game pieces were from the foam and cardstock, cut after being glued to magnet sheets.